A workplace accident is new information about a risk. Regulation 3 of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 requires an employer to review a risk assessment where there is reason to suspect that it is no longer valid, and HSE guidance treats accidents and near misses as reasons to consider a review. The CSI division of C2D Prévention supports organisations on this subject, with the Cause Tree (Arbre des Causes) support module to analyse the event and the safety assessment to observe real practices in the field. This article describes the path from accident analysis to a revised risk assessment and action plan.
An accident is never just an event to record: it is evidence that the risk assessment may no longer match the work as it is really done.
Why must a risk assessment be reviewed after a workplace accident ?
Regulation 3 of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 requires the employer to review a risk assessment where there is reason to suspect it is no longer valid, or where there has been a significant change in the matters it relates to. If the review shows that changes are needed, the employer must make them. HSE advises considering a review after any accident or near miss, in organisations of every size. The regulation sets no fixed calendar date: the assessment has to stay valid as events and changes occur.
HSE’s guide to investigating accidents and incidents (HSG245) presents an adverse event as an occasion to check whether the existing risk assessments were suitable and sufficient. The wider framework for reviews is detailed in our article Updating Your Risk Assessment: What UK Employers Need to Check.
A compliance issue comes with it. HSG245 warns that failing to review the relevant risk assessments after an event may breach the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999. Leaving the assessment untouched after an accident therefore creates both a safety gap and a compliance gap.
| What recording and consultation duties apply to each revision ?
Employers with five or more employees must record the significant findings of their risk assessment, and every revision should be recorded, dated and discussed with workers or their representatives. Regulation 3(6) sets the recording duty, and HSE recommends updating the assessment record with any changes. Employers must also consult their workers, directly or through safety representatives, on health and safety matters; HSG245 describes the involvement of employees as both a legal expectation and a practical benefit. Dating each version makes follow-up easier.
How should you analyse the accident before changing the assessment ?
The analysis relies on a team drawn from different roles, set up as soon as possible after the accident, which gathers the facts and then establishes the causes. HSG245 describes an investigation as a joint effort between management and the workforce: the team may include supervisors, line managers, health and safety professionals, trade union safety representatives, other employee representatives and senior management. It needs the skills to investigate and a direct route to those who can act on its recommendations.
HSE defines a near miss as an event that causes no harm but could have caused injury or ill health. We recommend recording all accidents, even minor ones, together with near misses. The information collected stays factual: observations, interviews, documents and measurements. HSG245 then distinguishes three levels of cause: immediate causes, such as a missing guard; underlying causes, such as inadequate checks or production pressure; and root causes, the management and organisational failures from which the others stem.
Would you like to review the prevention of serious accidents in your organisation? Talk to the C2D Prévention team about your sites and your priorities.
| Why look for causes rather than blame ?
The purpose of an investigation is to understand how the accident happened and to improve how the organisation works, not to name someone at fault. HSG245 makes the same point: blaming individuals makes people defensive and stops them cooperating, and human error should be traced back to the conditions that made it likely. The cause tree method examines the technical, organisational and human components of the system to work back to the root causes, and these are the causes to use when revising the risk assessment.
To equip managers and supervisors for this approach, C2D Prévention offers the Accident Investigation support module: in 3.5 hours, participants run an immersive investigation based on a field-inspired accident and learn to tell facts, testimonies and interpretations apart.
How do you carry the causes into the risk assessment and the action plan ?
The causes identified are entered against the relevant activity or work area, the risk is reassessed, and each action chosen is recorded with an owner, a deadline and an estimated cost. We recommend formalising corrective actions in an action plan that states these three elements, so that each action can be traced and followed up. Because the assessment is organised by activity or work area, it also shows where in the document the change belongs.
Five questions help to judge whether an action is relevant: is it stable over time, does it fit into daily work, does it move the risk elsewhere or create a new one, how far does it reach, and does it act on the root causes? The general principles of prevention add that collective protective measures take priority over individual ones (Schedule 1 to the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999).
| How can you check that the actions are working ?
Follow-up means checking that actions are delivered by the agreed dates, then assessing their effect in the field. A review of the relevant activity or work area a few weeks after implementation shows whether the reassessed risk has actually fallen. Feedback to the injured person and their colleagues is also worthwhile, to share the causes identified and help people take ownership of the actions. On the tools side, the Watson application from C2D Prévention tracks the resolution of reports and the action plan. The CAP method provides, in its Architect phase, for an action plan and a roadmap drawn up with senior management.
In short, reviewing the risk assessment after an accident follows four stages: analyse the facts with a team drawn from different roles, establish the immediate, underlying and root causes, enter them against the relevant activity with a dated action plan, then follow the results. C2D Prévention offers support modules for accident analysis and the CAP method to structure the action plan over time. The safety assessment complements the analysis by observing real practices, so that the risk assessment reflects the work as it is actually done in the field.
Key takeaways
- An accident is new information about a risk and a reason to review the risk assessment, whatever the size of the organisation.
- An analysis carried out by a team from different roles separates immediate, underlying and root causes, based on verifiable facts.
- The causes identified are used to reassess the risk in the relevant activity or work area, then to complete the action plan.
- Each action receives an owner, a deadline and an estimated cost, then is followed up and evaluated.
- Employers with five or more employees must record the significant findings; each revised version should be dated and discussed with workers or their representatives.
FAQ
Does a near miss also require the risk assessment to be reviewed ?
Regulation 3 requires a review where there is reason to suspect the assessment is no longer valid. A near miss whose analysis reveals such a reason falls within that scope. HSE advises considering a review after accidents and near misses, and HSG245 defines a near miss as an event that causes no harm but could have caused injury or ill health.
How soon should the risk assessment be reviewed after an accident ?
The regulations set no specific number of days. HSG245 links the investigation directly to a review of the relevant risk assessments, and regulation 3 requires the review where there is reason to suspect the assessment is no longer valid. We recommend setting up the analysis team as soon as possible after the accident.
Who takes part in analysing a workplace accident ?
HSG245 describes a joint effort between management and the workforce. Depending on the organisation, the team may include supervisors and line managers, health and safety professionals, trade union safety representatives or other employee representatives, and senior management. Employees who know the work as it is really done also contribute their knowledge.
Further reading
This article explains when to review a risk assessment, what to record and how to link it to real work.
This article describes five stages of a reporting process, from the first report to learning from experience.
This article details the direct and indirect costs of a workplace accident.
See also
a four-phase approach that starts with a diagnostic and leads to a controlled safety culture.
a conference on the legal and regulatory framework of health and safety at work.
Would you like to link the analysis of your accidents to the review of your risk assessment? Contact the C2D Prévention team to discuss your situation.
Sources
Health and Safety Executive (HSE). (2004). Investigating accidents and incidents: A workbook for employers, unions, safety representatives and safety professionals (HSG245). https://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/hsg245.pdf
Health and Safety Executive (HSE). (n.d.). Steps needed to manage risk. https://www.hse.gov.uk/simple-health-safety/risk/steps-needed-to-manage-risk.htm
The Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999, SI 1999/3242, regulation 3. legislation.gov.uk. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1999/3242/regulation/3
The Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999, SI 1999/3242, Schedule 1. legislation.gov.uk. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1999/3242/schedule/1
C2D Prévention. Cause Tree (Arbre des Causes) support module (page in French). https://www.c2dprevention.com/accompagnement-securite-et-coaching/modules-d-accompagnement/module-daccompagnement-arbre-des-causes/
C2D Prévention. Accident Investigation support module (page in French). https://www.c2dprevention.com/accompagnement-securite-et-coaching/modules-d-accompagnement/module-daccompagnement-enquete-accident/
C2D Prévention. Assessment: safety assessment for risk prevention and safety. https://www.c2dprevention.com/en/safety-coaching-support/assessment/
C2D Prévention. The CAP© method (page in French). https://www.c2dprevention.com/methode-cap/
C2D Prévention. Watson application: HSE software for reporting risks (page in French). https://www.c2dprevention.com/accompagnement-securite-et-coaching/application-watson/
C2D Prévention. Updating Your Risk Assessment: What UK Employers Need to Check. https://www.c2dprevention.com/en/blog-en/update-risk-assessment-uk/
C2D Prévention. How can you organise the reporting of hazardous situations, from first report to closing out the action? https://www.c2dprevention.com/en/blog-en/hazard-reporting-process/
C2D Prévention. How much does a workplace accident really cost your business? https://www.c2dprevention.com/en/blog-en/true-cost-workplace-accident/
